NIALL CRABTREE - GAME DESIGNER
Menu

How Cards Went from a 2.6 to an 8.2 in Lethal Deal - Lethal Deal Development Log

3/14/2022

Comments

 
Context: We have just finished our second sprint when developing a vertical slice for Lethal Deal. We are 8 weeks into our 12 week development cycle for this vertical slice. We have just conducted our second round of over-the-shoulder user testing. 
The Problem with Cards: In Lethal Deal, the implementation and engagement of card play was always going to be tricky. As a designer, that was kind of the point, I wanted a tough challenge to overcome. The difficulty of said challenge was confirmed when the quantitative results returned from the first round of user testing just over a week into development, 2.6 out of 10. The qualitative data confirmed that there was almost no want to engage in the mechanism, and the mechanic definitely felt tacked on to the player. 
Picture

Read More
Comments

Designing Card Drop Distribution with Machinations - Lethal Deal Development Log 5

2/23/2022

Comments

 
With a 12 week development cycle, often times as a designer I will try to limit as much iteration that we will need so we can work on implementing more features and polishing old ones. Machinations is a great tool to prototype systems and how they are going to function in game, especially when those systems use percentage chances. 
Picture
One feature that I want to implement is a card economy and rarity system into the card drop system and pack system that we have in the game. I feel like this is important because it allows us to lean more onto the TCG flavour of Lethal Deal.

​Check out below how the system is prototyped to work in a "pack" format. Press play to see it in action.

Read More
Comments

6 Ways to Make People Want to Read your Game Design Document - Lethal Deal Development Log 4

2/11/2022

Comments

 
At some point in life, every designer comes to the same realisation, nobody wants to read your GDD. Luckly, I figured this out well before Lethal Deal started development, so I could do my best to make the GDD for Lethal Deal as readable as possible.

Navigation
A game design document could seem to a lot of people as a monolith of text that is overwhelming and dense. So having a way for each member of the team to locate parts of the GDD relevant to their role without having to read through it all is essential. Using Google Docs built in header system is a great way to get team members to where they need to be quickly. 
Picture

Read More
Comments

Level Design Details - Lethal Deal Development Log 3

1/31/2022

Comments

 
Most players when traversing carefully designed levels never realise just how carefully that level was put together. With Lethal Deal, from the very first block out, I wanted to make sure the player never felt overwhelmed, confused, or lost. And on the flip side, I always wanted the player to feel powerful and in charge of their movement. The core design pillar of Lethal Deal is to make the player feel like a badass, and being overwhelmed by decisions isn't a great way to achieve that. 
Example 1: So many jumpads!!!
Picture
Problem: I noticed after finishing the first pass of the block out for the opening arena level that I was getting overwhelmed by the amount of glowing jumpads in my immediate view when I spawned in. My first instinct was to just remove some of the jumpads, but I knew that it would mess up the flow of movement that I had designed into the level. I've always found that it's better to try and make an aspect of a game work first before deciding to remove it.

Read More
Comments

User Testing - Lethal Deal Development Log 2

1/28/2022

Comments

 
Hello all and welcome back to another blog post about Lethal Deal, if you aren’t caught up on the development of Lethal Deal, please refer back to the previous blog post here. 
This post is all about user testing. After the first week of development I thought it essential to go out there and perform as many over-the-shoulder tests as I could in the span of just a couple of days. I am such a fan of iterative and feedback lead development, I thought planning our next phase of development with the aid of user feedback would be a great way to go. Here are the results of the tests as well as an example video of what the 14 tests looked like. These were all performed using the build from the fifth day of development.
Picture

Read More
Comments

The First Game Jam - Lethal Deal Development Log 1

1/24/2022

Comments

 
​Hello! This post is about the "team project" module for my final year on the games design degree at the University of Huddersfield. This is the first of a series of development posts relating to Lethal Deal, a vertical slice for a video game I am working on with seven other people who form the team
​Inline 9. ​We have a 12-week development cycle, including three game jam weeks (40+ hours Monday to Friday) and nine regular weeks (16+ hours Monday to Friday). 
Picture

Read More
Comments

I'm going to make a FREE Roll and Write game for Christmas!

12/7/2021

Comments

 
​Why?
In game design class today, the tutor brought up itch.io to discuss puzzle games. On the site there was a game that essentially used roll and write mechanics in the form of creating your own forest with sudoku like rule sets (except without the harsh punishment of having to start over if you get something wrong).
​
The reason why I mention this is because I have always been interested in making a free game for people to download, especially around the holiday time. However, due to my like of expertise when it comes to art, I thought this would be economically not viable due to the need for artwork. This along with my lack of experience with creating print and play games really put this dream on the back burner for the last two years. However, since running two Kickstarters which had a print and play pledge, and also discovering how amazing roll and write games can be, and just how unique you can make them, I have decided that I am going to challenge myself to create a small, fun roll and write game for people to enjoy over the holidays. These series of blog posts are going to document this brief journey.
​

Read More
Comments

The BIG Downside to Over Rewarding Players in Games

12/2/2021

Comments

 
A couple of months ago in one of my recent iterations for one of my upcoming games, I tested out how players would respond to increasing the amount of points you get for essentially every single action in the game.

Context: In the game, you get points for completing route cards by going to planets, and that’s it.


What I changed: I made it so that you get points for going to any destination, you get points if you rolled a specific dice face, and you also get points if you do your character specific goal. (This could be as simple as moving to a specific destination a number of times in a round, or gaining a certain resource).

Read More
Comments

The Difference between QA and Playtesting in Games

11/23/2021

Comments

 
It has only come to light recently in my discussions with other developers, as well as tutors at my University, that when I say I playtested Food Time Battle in Space for six months, or that I’ve been playtesting Space Game for three months now, that I’m just plain wrong. 

If we look back at the development of FTBS, it took me roughly about a month to work out all the kinks, and make sure that the game is playable and enjoyable. Due to the game being so tightly designed yet very asymmetric (I only had 12 cards to work with for each player to create and balance that asymmetry) it then took me five months to balance the game. To break that down more simply, development on FTBS was split into:
  • 1 Month Playtesting
  • 5 Months Quality Assurance (QA)

This blog post is going to briefly cover the key difference between the two, as well as discuss what your aims should likely be whilst in these two different phases of development.

Read More
Comments

The Advantages of Making Board Games (that isn't money).

11/18/2021

Comments

 
I have been selling games for four years now and I have never made any money. I’ve generated income to pay for manufacturing, distribution, conventions and marketing material. I have even generated enough income to support five amazing and talented freelancers at various points in time over the last four years of my board game development journey. Still, my board game development company has yet to turn a profit. 

Now I’m not saying that you can’t make money from board games, or even that I can’t make money from board games, I’m sure that I will in the next couple of years just due to compounding effects. However, the point is that this is coming from the perspective of someone who has been working flat out full time for the last four years, developing three games and growing a business from the ground up, and hasn’t been rewarded monetarily for their efforts. 

Here’s 5 reasons why you should definitely make board games:

Read More
Comments
<<Previous

    Author

    Hello, my name is Niall Crabtree, and this is my comprehensive blog showcasing all of my game development 
    ​endeavors and successes, as well as essays on game design.

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020

    Mailing List

    Receive an email every two weeks with all the articles I produce so you never miss one!
    * indicates required

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Projects
  • Blog
    • Lethal Deal
    • Langskip
    • Food Time Battle in Space
    • Blockers: The Stacking Game
  • Talks & Interviews
  • Contact Me
  • —————————
  • Video Essays
  • Podcast
  • Mailing List Sign Up
  • Home
  • Projects
  • Blog
    • Lethal Deal
    • Langskip
    • Food Time Battle in Space
    • Blockers: The Stacking Game
  • Talks & Interviews
  • Contact Me
  • —————————
  • Video Essays
  • Podcast
  • Mailing List Sign Up